Why we're staying out of South Florida — and doubling down on Jacksonville and Orlando
Everyone still treats Miami, Broward, and Palm Beach as the default Florida trade. The data quietly stopped agreeing with that a while ago.
We get asked at least once a month why we don't have a single South Florida position in the pipeline, given how much capital is still chasing Miami-Dade and Broward. The honest answer is that we looked hard, twice, and the numbers talked us out of it both times. Not the vibes — the actual filings, the insurance data, and the migration counts. This is what we found.
The carrying cost gap is enormous, and it isn't closing
Florida's statewide average homeowners insurance premium is projected at roughly $8,458 a year in 2026 — about three times the national average. But "statewide average" hides the real story, because Florida isn't one insurance market, it's six or seven regional ones stacked on top of each other. On a comparable dwelling, Miami-Dade is running somewhere in the $12,000–$20,000 range depending on coastal proximity, Broward is close behind at roughly $9,750, and the Keys are north of $14,800. Orange and Seminole counties — the core of the Orlando market — are sitting around $2,180–$3,645. Northeast Florida, where Jacksonville sits, runs a similar $2,185–$4,005. That's not a modest discount. That's a three-to-five-times difference in annual carrying cost before a single dollar of purchase price is on the table, and it applies every year the asset is held.
To be fair to South Florida, 2026 is actually the first year in nearly a decade this is getting better, not worse. Citizens Property Insurance approved an average statewide rate cut of 8.7%, with Broward seeing cuts closer to 17% and Miami-Dade around 10–14%, as tort reform and new private carriers finally start working through the system. We think that's a genuinely good development for existing owners. It doesn't change our read on new positions, though — even after the cut, coastal South Florida premiums are still multiples of what they are eighty miles inland. The gap is narrowing. It isn't closing.
The condo math changed on January 1, and it isn't a small change
Following the 2021 Surfside collapse, Florida gave condo buildings a multi-year grace period before enforcing stricter structural and reserve requirements. That grace period ended on January 1, 2026. Any condo building three stories or taller now has to complete milestone structural inspections and fully fund its reserves — boards can no longer vote to waive or underfund them. The practical result has been a wave of special assessments, some running into six figures per unit in older coastal buildings, on top of master-policy insurance increases that have doubled HOA dues in some Miami-Dade and Tampa Bay buildings. None of that shows up in a listing price. It shows up eight months after closing.
The migration data flipped, and most people haven't noticed yet
Here's the part that actually moved us off South Florida entirely, not just cautious about condos. Miami-Dade posted the largest domestic outflow of any high-flood-risk county in the country in the most recent full year of Census data — roughly 67,000 more people left than arrived — and it's one of only a handful of major counties nationally, alongside Los Angeles, that's shrinking in absolute numeric terms. Multiple large coastal metros, Miami included, would already be losing population outright if not for international migration, which has itself slowed sharply over the past year.
Compare that to what's happening ninety minutes north. Orlando added the tenth-most residents of any U.S. region last year and grew jobs at 1.3%, ahead of both the state and national rate — and the region's own long-range forecast has it adding more total jobs over the next decade than Miami, a metro with twice its population. Jacksonville is on pace for roughly 18,000 to 22,000 net new residents this year, and critically, the drivers behind that number aren't a single employer announcement or a pandemic-era remote-work spike. They're structural: no state income tax, strong school districts pulling in St. Johns County specifically, and a durable cost gap versus the metros people are leaving. Structural reasons for growth tend to persist. Vibes-based growth doesn't.
Don't buy the hype. Follow the data.
None of this means South Florida is broken or that every deal down there is a bad one. It means the market has gotten expensive to carry, more legally complicated to build in, and demographically softer than the headlines still suggest, all at the same time investors keep pricing it like nothing changed. We'd rather be early to the correction than late to the party. For now, that means Jacksonville and Orlando get our attention, and South Florida gets a pass — not because we don't like it there, but because that's what the permits, the premiums, and the population counts are actually telling us.
This post reflects the author's independent analysis of publicly available insurance, migration, and housing market data as of mid-2026, and is offered for informational and commentary purposes only. It is not investment advice and does not constitute an offer to sell or a solicitation to buy any security. Market conditions change; verify current data before making any investment decision.